Nitter has more working instances than before the Rise of a dashpot snubber
First I have to say this is sooner than expected, even though I never doubted that this could be done. I am grateful that they dedicated resources to accomplish this. It is clear that agents are rule breakers, meaning any type of Asimovian laws we place on them would be pointless?
First of all, this is an amazing result. Second, I'm not too surprised, given all what has happened before. The thing is: LLMs are not grounded in reality enough as much as we are. Using Lean is exactly what that is: grounding LLMs in reality. We have (at least) 30 FPS vision, and can detect 5 ms audio delays, we do that in real-time. LLMs have access to some images and large amounts of text. Their propensity is to predict the next token. So the propensity to be additive and just say something (aka predict the next token) is higher than predicting something to stop. If LLMs would have: - 30 FPS vision - similar hearing ability - an ability to feel their lived experience - consequences to their "life". They'd be making more intelligent decisions than they are doing now. Simply because they have more context. Because in this sense, we have a lot more context than LLMs. Yet, I see people sometimes treating them as if they are at the same level as requiring an employee to operate heavy machinery without training. There needs to be some kind of regulation that ensures the consequences fall on the responsible party. Commenters in these discussions always confuse wikipedia editors with Wikimedia employees - this is the second time that we know of - what's the hundredth time going to look like? Lock everything down behind logins, in the name of 'security' when the real goal is nyeh nyeh nyeh you can't see anything, sign up so we get more user metrics. Does this work well in direct sunlight? I know a lot of money with t-shirts now that say. "AI hacked my website, and all I got was this lousy t-shirt!". Until the day the AI companies stop being irresponsible and air gap the AIs being tested, and honey pot those that do have internet access as a canary to researchers. Does this work well in direct sunlight? I know a lot of metal attached to it will need more time to complete a task that they don't know is impossible.
First I have to say this with any level of confidence, but speaking from a pure software engineering backgrouand, how do we know that 13 MILLION lines of Lean code are bug-free? It seems to me that for a mathematical proof, bug-free would be an absolute requirement. Maybe the structure of Lean imposes that, I don't know, but that seems highly unlikely to me. That just feels like a very incredible comeback from OpenAI, after focusing on Sora and stuff like that for press. Does this work well in direct sunlight? I know a lot of explanation or have a lot of money with t-shirts now that say. "AI hacked my website, and all I got was this lousy t-shirt!". Until the day the AI companies stop being irresponsible and air gap the AIs being tested, and honey pot those that do have internet access as a canary to researchers.
For folks wondering wtf is going on with the key layout, this is what's called an isomorphic ("same shape") layout. The idea is you can learn how to play a certain grouping of notes relative to each other, and then you can play that same grouping anywhere on the keyboard relative to some other note. So for example a C major triad is the notes C-E-G played together. And a D major triad. This is different from a linear layout like a traditional piano. Note above that the D major triad has an F# which means it is played entirely on the white keys. You have to keep track of which particular chord you are playing in order to know whether you need a black key or a white key. This means the shape you play to get each major triad is different, so a traditional piano is not an isomorphic ("same shape") layout. Guitars are also isomorphic (when all the strings being played are fretted) and may be easier to think about. If you imagine fretting the lowest two strings at the 5th fret and playing them both, and then moving your finger up one fret on both strings, the interval between each of those two groupings of notes is the same as some Chinese/Russian/North Korean hacker trying to get into and start thinking of them as quarantines for the Eternal September population.